Two blades with the same measurements
On Tokyo National Museum’s English records, two famous swords have an unexpected feature in common. The blade length given for each is eighty centimetres and the curvature is 2.7 centimetres. One is the Kyōto work called Mikazuki Munechika, the other the Hōki work called Dōjigiri Yasutsuna. Photographed against a neutral ground and reduced to the size of a printed page, either might appear to be the twin of the other. A curator could spend an entire morning explaining the differences those two measurements leave out. The explanations would range from the distribution of a curve to the identity of a woman who made a consequential bequest.
The easiest way to begin is to read the names as the museum prints them. The first object is a tachi signed Sanjō, celebrated as Mikazuki Munechika. The second is signed Yasutsuna, celebrated as Dōjigiri Yasutsuna. Each label puts an inscription within a longer name by which later generations remembered the blade. Both works are Japanese National Treasures. That is a modern designation. The inscriptions, traditional names and designations arrived at different moments, and it is the space between those moments that gives the two objects their distinctive histories.
For readers coming from accounts of the Tenka Goken, the pair offers a welcome change of scale. That celebrated group of five belongs to the history of reputation. Membership tells us which works later people chose to bring together. It does relatively little to explain how to recognize a crescent in a photograph, which portion of a mounting belongs to a museum entry, or whether an Ashikaga connection has been documented equally well for every member. For those questions the evidence becomes more precise when the reader leaves the list and follows a single object at a time.
A curve that changes as the eye travels
Begin at the base of the Sanjō blade and follow its outline toward the tip. The Japanese museum commentary describes pronounced curvature near the tang and lower part of the blade, with little curvature toward the point. A simple arc drawn with a compass would continue bending at the same rate throughout. The profile visible here changes character along its length. The single catalogue figure for sori, the depth of curvature, records a maximum displacement from a reference line. It cannot tell a reader which portion of the profile is chiefly responsible for the impression of movement.
The difference is particularly apparent if one looks first at the outer silhouette and then at the space between the silhouette and an imagined straight line joining its ends. Near the base the eye meets an expansion in width and a strong turn. Farther along it follows a quieter, narrowing passage. The word funbari is used in descriptions of old tachi for the impression of breadth and strength at the base as the blade narrows away. It describes part of what a spectator sees in an outline. It is quite distinct from a unit of measurement, and there is no numerical funbari field beside the museum’s curvature figure.

The e-Museum entry gives a further length for Mikazuki Munechika, 85.3 centimetres for the scabbard. This number matters because online compilations sometimes borrow measurements without copying the noun. A scabbard must accommodate an object and has distinct ends and fittings of its own. Its length has a place in the object history, especially when a curator must identify which piece is present in an exhibition. Substituting its figure for the blade length would add more than five centimetres to a blade that has not changed at all. The short list of numbers is already a miniature inventory.
Heian is another description whose apparent simplicity can be misleading. The museum places both blades within a broad range from the tenth to the twelfth century. A visitor who writes down only “eleventh century” could inadvertently turn the middle of a range into an event known to have happened in a particular century. This caution matters more for an early smith than it does for an artist whose signed inscription specifies a year and a month. The outline, the signature and comparisons with other early material contribute evidence, but the museum has deliberately published a range.
Where to look for the crescent
The name Mikazuki means crescent moon. In this case its point of reference is a detail on the blade itself. Japan Search’s illustrated survey associates the name with uchinoke, small crescent forms near the boundary of the hardened region. They are local features rather than the sweeping curvature of the tachi as a whole. This is an unusually satisfying detail to discover in an enlarged museum view. At first glance the profile itself might suggest a moon. A closer reading of the record directs attention from an obvious outline to a feature that takes a little patience to see.
| Catalogue feature | Mikazuki Munechika | Dōjigiri Yasutsuna |
|---|---|---|
| Inscription | Sanjō | Yasutsuna |
| Historical association | Kyoto and the Sanjō tradition | Hōki and its early smiths |
| Name in the catalogue | Crescents visible within the hardened area | An encounter with Shuten Dōji in literary tradition |
| Present collection | Tokyo National Museum | Tokyo National Museum |
Compare each accession separately, including the signature and the surface described in the entry.
Sources · Tokyo National Museum, Mikazuki · Tokyo National Museum, Dōjigiri
A polished blade reflects a gallery’s lighting unevenly. Small alterations in the direction and size of the light source can change which details become legible in a photograph. A photographer who has made the silhouette perfectly clear may have recorded relatively little of the surface. Conversely, a detailed view may reveal contrasting lines and particles while giving a poor sense of the whole form. The shift is a matter of what the photograph was made to show. It explains why a visitor comparing reproductions should find the museum’s detail views before deciding that a feature mentioned in the label is absent.
A useful comparison inside the same museum is Kikkō Sadamune. Its celebrated name refers to a mark resembling a tortoise shell on the tang, a chrysanthemum set within a hexagonal figure. Here a name also invites the viewer to look for a particular shape, yet it directs attention to a different part of a different object. A person who understood every poetic blade name to describe the hamon would be looking in entirely the wrong place. Curatorial explanations of names often double as directions to the part of a museum photograph that deserves another look.

Sanjō introduces another kind of evidence. The two characters in the inscription are the ones transcribed in the object title. Munechika is the smith to whom the work is assigned. The place association evokes the capital and the early history of its sword makers. It would be a small but consequential error to repeat the entire familiar name as the inscription. When a researcher traces an old inventory, the distinction can decide whether a short entry matches this object. A catalogue that preserves both the literal inscription and the received attribution gives the reader two ways of recognizing the work.
Hōki as seen through one signed survivor
Yasutsuna is associated with Hōki, a historical province on the Sea of Japan side of western Honshū. Ko-Hōki, or old Hōki, is a grouping used to discuss early work from that setting. The Cultural Heritage Online entry for Dōjigiri calls attention to the small, irregular changes within its komidare hamon. The description asks for patient looking along a succession of local variations. The interest lies in their relationship to one another and to the visible steel surface. A photograph taken to reproduce the whole outline may show only the broadest of these distinctions.

Jihada is the term a reader encounters for the visible texture of the worked steel. It can be described through comparisons with the grain of wood, an analogy for appearance rather than an identification of the material. A related museum record for a blade signed Yasuie describes a narrow shape, a strong curve nearer the hilt, a discernible wood-grain-like surface and small irregularities in the hamon. The museum also remarks on points of comparison with early Bizen workmanship. Regional classification here generates a question about connections between makers. It leaves room for resemblance across provincial boundaries.
That comparison has an important limit. A description made of Yasuie cannot simply be transferred word for word to Yasutsuna. A statement such as “Hōki work sometimes displays a conspicuous grain” belongs to the level of comparative scholarship. A statement that a particular photograph shows a specific feature at a certain location requires inspection of that particular photograph. Keeping the two levels separate has a practical benefit. Unusual features remain visible, instead of being written out of a record because they do not resemble what a curator has been taught to expect from a school.
The measurement most often asked about in connection with Dōjigiri is its length. The English national e-Museum gives 80.0 centimetres. The alternative 79.9 centimetres circulating in summaries differs by a millimetre. A difference of this order might arise through recording or rounding, but that is a possibility rather than an explanation established for these two numbers. The figure that can be reproduced from the record cited here is 80.0. The accession number F-19931 lets another reader return to the same entry and, if a future catalogue reports a different measurement, identify precisely which value changed.
A bequest, two households and one misleading shortcut
The ownership story of Mikazuki Munechika has a particularly well-defined passage. Tokyo National Museum records it in the possession of Kōdai-in, the wife of Toyotomi Hideyoshi, and relates that she bequeathed it to Tokugawa Hidetada. The transaction matters in its own right. A frequently repeated shorthand that moves directly from the Toyotomi name to the Tokugawa name can make a highly consequential woman seem like an incidental link in the chain. The museum’s wording gives her the agency that a list of male military rulers can easily obscure.
The Dōjigiri entry also mentions Hideyoshi and Hidetada, alongside Tokugawa Ieyasu. A Japanese cultural heritage record traces the blade through the Ashikaga and Tokugawa shogunal houses and the Echizen and Tsuyama Matsudaira. A familiar name appearing in both pedigrees can give the impression that the two objects travelled together. That proposition would require evidence of a shared transfer or a dated inventory listing both. Recording a shared association with a household is a more modest observation. It is also historically more interesting than a single unbroken itinerary assembled from the most prominent names in each account.
There is a similar temptation to extend an Ashikaga connection from one of the national records to the other. For Dōjigiri the cultural heritage description explicitly names that house. For Mikazuki the English record supplies a clear, later bequest. These sources support different sentences. Earlier ownership of Mikazuki can be a subject for further documentary research without being filled in by analogy. A genealogy of ownership is most useful when the reader can tell where a transaction is specifically described, where continuity is reported at household level, and where a gap remains.
Another tachi identified by a family name in Tokyo National Museum, the Uesugi tachi illustrated here, offers a visual reminder of that problem. A title connecting an object with a family encourages research into the nature and date of the connection. It cannot by itself name the person who commissioned every component or establish the order of every subsequent transfer. Even the most apparently straightforward names may preserve only a particular episode in many centuries of custody. Some identify what people saw on the steel, while others preserve the circumstances in which later generations came to know it.

When the demon enters the catalogue
Dōjigiri is linked with the story of the warrior Minamoto no Yorimitsu, also known as Raikō, and the demon Shuten Dōji. The museum presents this association as tradition. A narrative of the defeat of a dangerous being makes an extraordinary explanation for the reputation of a treasured object. It is also a story with a long artistic life, retold in texts and illustrated in paintings and prints. A painted version has historical value even when it cannot identify a specific surviving blade. It tells us how a later audience imagined the event and which details made the story recognizable to them.
The Machida tradition is another episode that belongs to the reception of the sword. In later retellings, the name Machida and a claim of six bodies accompany an extraordinary story of a cutting test. The two national object records cited here provide neither a contemporary test report nor measurements from such an event. That gap is significant. A report repeated in the history of a celebrated object is evidence of the kind of reputation attached to it. It cannot supply experimental data about its metallurgy, and it certainly does not establish anything about the circumstances in which the Heian smith made it.
The sources that might illuminate such a story have quite different strengths. A signed, dated inscription could establish that a named person had a statement recorded at a given time. A household inventory could show that a blade was present when the inventory was compiled. A printed compilation could establish that an episode was already in circulation by its date of publication. None would automatically establish every detail retold in a later narrative. The first question for a reader interested in Machida should therefore concern the earliest identifiable witness to the account. A more spectacular version published later does not move that witness closer to the events.
What the associated objects preserve
Dōjigiri’s full Japanese record lists an associated mounting and a lacquered sword box. The terms used for the box identify a pear-skin ground and scattered hollyhock crests in maki-e. Such details give the history of custody a tangible dimension that lists of eminent owners alone cannot convey. People housed, moved, identified and preserved the blade. A box decorated for a later household belongs to that history even if it contributes nothing directly to the date of the original smith’s work. The name of an accompanying object in a museum title is often a clue to a second set of historical questions.
The Mikazuki record likewise includes an associated scabbard of the thread-wrapped slung-sword type. Its inclusion explains the second measurement with which we began. It also makes clear how a modern display can divide a historical ensemble for the visitor’s benefit. Showing the bare blade enables a close look at the crescent forms. Showing its housing can restore a sense of the work as a treasured possession kept within a household. A museum may emphasize one or the other according to the exhibition. An online entry that records both can outlast any particular arrangement in the gallery.
For exhibition research, there is one small habit that makes all these comparisons easier. Keep the two accession numbers in the margin of the notebook and record which language version of the entry supplied a quotation or figure. The English page spells some names differently from a modern romanized title. The Japanese page can retain names for fittings that a short English heading omits. An enlarged image may show something neither caption singles out. Keeping these records alongside each other leaves a path back to the evidence for the next reader, even after a museum updates its translation or reorganizes its photographs.
The most enduring distinction between these two National Treasures is therefore not a millimetre on a measuring scale. On one, a spectator has to find the small crescents that gave the object its name and follow the trail of a woman’s bequest. On the other, an early provincial attribution, an evocative surface, an elaborate history of custody and a vivid demon legend ask different things of the reader. The two belong side by side because the comparison makes each easier to see. Their equal published length turns out to be the beginning of a conversation that no pair of measurements could finish.
Frequently asked questions
Where are Mikazuki Munechika and Dōjigiri Yasutsuna kept?
Both are National Treasures held by Tokyo National Museum. Their accession numbers are F-20103 and F-19931, respectively.
Why is Munechika called Mikazuki?
The name refers to crescent forms seen near the hamon. Japan Search identifies the feature as uchinoke.
What name is signed on Mikazuki Munechika?
The museum transcribes the signature as Sanjō and identifies the maker as Sanjō Munechika.
How long is Dōjigiri Yasutsuna?
The national e-Museum record lists 80.0 centimetres and curvature of 2.7 centimetres. Those are catalogue measurements of the blade.
Who owned Mikazuki Munechika?
Tokyo National Museum records Kōdai-in and her bequest to Tokugawa Hidetada. Later Tokugawa custody belongs to the history of this particular sword.
Does the museum verify the Shuten Dōji episode?
The national catalogue presents the connection with Minamoto no Yorimitsu and Shuten Dōji as a legendary explanation of the name.
Films and talks
The Met — Art of the Samurai—An Introduction
The Met — The Japanese Sword and the Japanese Aesthetic
Collection records and further reading
- Tokyo National Museum, Mikazuki Munechika, F-20103
- Tokyo National Museum, Dōjigiri Yasutsuna, F-19931
- Cultural Heritage Online, Dōjigiri and the Matsudaira collection
- Japan Search, illustrated sword records and terminology
- National Institutes for Cultural Heritage, Yasuie of Hōki
- Tokyo National Museum, Kikkō Sadamune
- Tenka Goken (天下五剣): The History and Metallurgy of Japan's Five Greatest Swords Under Heaven
