Five Classic Japanese Hamon Styles: Comparing Suguha, Gunome, Choji, Notare, and Hitatsura

Five words and two different questions

A blade in a museum case offers at least two outlines. One is the silhouette of the metal against its surroundings. The other runs inside the metal, sometimes as quiet as the margin of an old drawing, sometimes breaking into high points, low bays and groups that suggest plants or clouds. The Japanese word hamon belongs to the second outline and the visible activity associated with it. Learning to see the space between the two is a better introduction than memorizing five silhouettes on flash cards. Even a fairly straight hamon can follow a visibly curving blade.

A question that often follows is which of five names to put on a particular sword. Four of our words describe the course or shape of a pattern: suguha, gunome, choji and notare. The fifth, hitatsura, shifts attention to how far visible effects extend across the surface. A curator can therefore describe an edge pattern with one of the first four words and still use the fifth for the blade as a whole. Recognizing that change of question resolves a puzzle that a chart of five mutually exclusive types would actually create.

The objects in this guide retain their individual identities. Tokyo National Museum's Ishida Masamune comes with a description that expressly uses two pattern terms. Another record concerns a sword attributed to Mitsutada despite the loss of its signature. The Metropolitan Museum of Art holds a short sword with a mounting, whose catalogue distinguishes the dates and makers of its components. A detail can be beautifully persuasive in all three cases. Its historical value comes from being able to return from the detail to the object, then from the object to the collection record.

Suguha and the meaning of a straight course

Suguha describes an overall course that reads as straight in relation to the edge. The word says nothing by itself about the width of the hardened region. Imagine drawing the path of the boundary along a photograph with the eye. If that path keeps a fairly even distance from the cutting edge over an extended passage, straight is a useful description, however curved the silhouette appears against the background. An absolutely horizontal line drawn across the printed page would be a poor test. Its position depends on how an editor rotated the photograph.

Five ways to recognize a hamon
Pattern Outline Tradition Nie and nioi Collection example
Suguha Narrow, nearly straight course Yamashiro and other traditions Can show bright nie along a straight boundary. Shintōgo Kunimitsu tantō, Sano Art Museum.
Gunome Repeated peaks; one shoulder may rise sharply Bizen Osafune; also Mino Fine or individually visible particles can outline the peaks. Koryū Kagemitsu, Tokyo National Museum.
Chōji Clove-shaped heads above narrower stems Bizen Ichimonji Often nioi-dominant; nie may also be present. Sanchōmō, Bizen Osafune Sword Museum.
Notare Long, gently undulating swells Sōshū; later Bizen interpretations Nie can articulate a swell that also contains gunome. Ishida Masamune, Tokyo National Museum.
Hitatsura Islands of hardening above the main boundary Sōshū and Hasebe Often rich in nie; the distribution across the face identifies the style. Wakizashi attributed to Fusamune, Metropolitan Museum.

Outline and particle appearance are recorded separately. Some museum descriptions use two pattern names for the same blade.

Sources · NBTHK pattern guide · Sano collection · Sanchōmō record

A straight course also leaves plenty to look at. The rim can appear fine and sharply defined in one exposure, soft and luminous in another. Minute features may cross or gather at it. Where the blade approaches its point, the surface changes orientation and the pattern can become hard to follow even in a good full-length view. The catalogue term for the pattern in the point is boshi. A description of the boshi supplies information about a particular place that the broad term suguha leaves open. It is worth preserving both observations when the museum provides them.

Atsushi Tōshirō, tantō, Tokyo National Museum, via ColBase
Atsushi Tōshirō, tantō, Tokyo National Museum, via ColBase. Tokyo National Museum, via ColBase.

The signed short blade Atsushi Toshiro gives the eye a particularly compact field. Tokyo National Museum records a length of just under twenty-eight centimetres and no curvature. The name Atsushi refers to unusual thickness. The museum’s short English entry praises the surface and the pattern but leaves the detailed vocabulary to the viewer or a fuller catalogue. Here is a case where silhouette, proportions and edge activity answer different questions. Its straight profile is perfectly good evidence about curvature. Taken alone, that profile cannot tell us which word a specialist would choose for the hardened boundary.

Scale changes what a visitor can responsibly say about an object like this. In a small printed reproduction the entire blade may be shorter than the width of a hand. A line that looks perfectly level on that page may resolve into several delicate movements when enlarged. Both images can be faithful within their limits. A useful description would tell the reader which impression persists across the full length and where a detail modifies it. Such a sentence can convey more than assigning the object to a school on the strength of one narrow band.

Gunome and the rhythm of unequal peaks

With gunome the interval between successive rises matters. Seen along a stretch of the blade, the pattern has a rhythm of hills and hollows. A diagram often regularizes that rhythm for teaching, rather as a music textbook prints evenly spaced notes. In an object photograph some peaks may have broad shoulders, others a narrow crown. The valleys may open or close. The recurrence gives the term its usefulness even where no two units are quite alike. A single hump in a tightly cropped image offers very little evidence about recurrence.

In descriptions of Osafune work the compound kataochi-gunome is especially helpful. It directs attention to an asymmetry that makes one side of a unit seem to drop away. The national collection entry for a dated work by Kanemitsu explicitly relates this pattern to his father Kagemitsu, then describes a change toward a more gently undulating style. The observation has a historical subject, an artist whose work could change. It would be misleading to turn the entry into a permanent rule for every generation working in Bizen or even every blade signed by either man.

Koryū Kagemitsu, Tokyo National Museum, via ColBase
Koryū Kagemitsu, Tokyo National Museum, via ColBase. Tokyo National Museum, via ColBase.

A separate record gives an unusually firm point of reference within that family history. The inscription on the Koryu Kagemitsu names Osafune in Bizen and dates the blade to the fifth month of a year corresponding to 1322. Its popular name refers to a small dragon that seems to peer out from a groove. The dragon can be identified and described independently of the hamon. In a classroom photograph it may be the first feature anyone notices. Once the image is located by that carving, the eye can return to the band near the edge and follow a different sort of mark across the same steel.

There is a valuable distinction here between a museum's account of the individual blade and its account of a family of makers. The date and dragon belong to this particular tachi. The changing fortunes of a pattern emerge from comparing several works and consulting more than one catalogue entry. Combining those sources gives the object a place in history. Combining their statements indiscriminately would give the impression that every development in the Osafune family could be seen in this one photograph. The signed date makes comparison possible without making all the examples interchangeable.

Choji and the scale of the clove

The clove in choji is a dried flower bud. Picturing the bulb at the top and the narrower part beneath it makes the word easier to remember. In a group, the high portions may crowd into one another, and a taller cluster may emerge above its neighbours. The comparison evokes a shape. It does not require the individual peaks to resemble finely drawn botanical specimens. On steel there can be passages where the overall impression is strongly floral although several constituent shapes would be quite difficult to name in isolation.

Tokyo National Museum describes an unsigned work attributed to Mitsutada that makes this language tangible. Its record names both cloves and a variety likened to tadpoles. It also distinguishes a misty formation in the ground steel running alongside the hamon. A viewer who follows only the brightest strip in an evenly lit image might easily switch from the boundary to that adjacent formation without noticing. Reading the account first gives the viewer a reason to look for two related paths. Each belongs to the description of the object, but they occupy different parts of its surface.

Some Bizen examples invite comparison with the Uesugi blade called Sanchomo. Here the celebrated layered appearance is important at a scale larger than a single clove. The pattern builds up in groups, giving the eye several possible routes through a passage. A catalogue photograph taken square to the blade can record their relative positions. A close detail may convey their density much better. The name of the object and the Bizen association will help a reader find the right record. Neither by itself establishes which variation of choji is visible at a particular point in the image.

An analogy with a woodblock print is helpful if used sparingly. From a distance an observer can recognize a cluster of blossoms as one shape. From close up the same cluster becomes a set of individual petals and intervening spaces. In choji the spacing and relationship of groups matter in much the same way. The analogy ends there. There is no painted petal on the steel, and its appearance changes substantially with the lighting. The photograph records a meeting between the object's surface, its state of polish and the photographer's choices about what to show.

Notare and the long view

Notare is often translated as an undulating or wavelike course. To see the distinction from gunome it helps to widen the field of view. A long, easy swell can carry smaller, more emphatic peaks along its margin. In a close detail those peaks may command all the attention. In a full view the change in height of the underlying band is more readily apparent. Both observations describe the same passage. They ask the viewer to attend to different intervals. A small crop printed without its position on the blade can make the broader observation impossible.

Ishida Masamune, Tokyo National Museum
Ishida Masamune, Tokyo National Museum. Kakidai, via Wikimedia Commons. License.

The Ishida Masamune is an especially generous test of that distinction because the museum resolves the apparent dilemma in words. Its entry names a gently undulating course together with large gunome. It goes on to describe fine bright threads and features compared to swept sand. Those appear at a finer scale again. The record also notes marks of damage at particular locations and gives a documentary account of its succession of owners. Each kind of evidence has its own vocabulary. A scar, a bright thread, a repeating peak and a long wave can all be present without being alternative explanations for the same mark.

The image rewards two readings in succession. Take in the blade as a long shape, noting where the activity comes relatively close to the edge and where it occupies more of the face. Then return to a shorter passage and consider whether its individual rises repeat. A visitor following the museum's description can look for both. Where reflection swallows the boundary it is reasonable to leave a gap in the description. Connecting the last visible feature to the next with an imagined smooth line would impose exactly the kind of regularity the object is being consulted to test.

The combination also complicates simple geographical maps. A diagram that assigns waves to one school and repeated peaks to another can help a beginner remember a few associations. The Ishida blade preserves the evidence that these associations have limits. The Osafune Kanemitsu record gives a second reason for caution by explicitly discussing a shift in style associated with influence from Soshu. Museums can trace relationships between centres and generations precisely because makers shared and varied visual ideas. An absolute border between pattern terms would hide part of the historical story those terms help us recover.

Hitatsura and the shape of the whole surface

A sentence about hitatsura begins in a different place. Look at the relationship between the main hardened band and activity elsewhere on the face, including areas that appear detached from it. The overall impression can be of irregular patches distributed across much of the steel. The term is therefore compatible with more specific descriptions of the shape near the edge. It also explains why an image cropped in the manner of a decorative border can be especially unsatisfactory here. The parts thrown away by the crop may supply the decisive evidence.

Blade and Mounting for a Short Sword (Wakizashi); attributed to Fusamune of Soshu, 2007.478.1a–i
Blade and Mounting for a Short Sword (Wakizashi); attributed to Fusamune of Soshu, 2007.478.1a–i. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Open Access.

The Metropolitan Museum's wakizashi attributed to Fusamune of Soshu offers an instructive example. The collection description specifically identifies hitatsura in the blade. The catalogue presents the blade together with later mounting elements and gives the object group a single main entry. A reader who arrives on a photograph dominated by scabbard or fittings should use the museum's other views to locate the steel under discussion. The decoration of the mounting has its own makers, materials and chronology. Their presence in the same accession is part of the work's historical interest and a reason to specify exactly which part a caption describes.

A bright island above an edge in one photograph is a weak basis for an attribution. It might be the feature the catalogue has described, a reflection, an interruption in the surface or a detail altogether too small for the exposure. A curator who describes hitatsura has considered the distribution over more than one tiny patch. This is a good point to compare views in the same collection record, checking whether the feature occupies the same place relative to a stable landmark. When the views do not settle the question, the catalogue and the visible image can be reported separately.

The fifth term also changes how one thinks about copying a pattern on paper. A single line drawn from the base to the tip can convey something of the difference between straight, swelling, repeating and clustered margins. A line drawing of hitatsura with all the space above that line left blank would omit essential information. A drawing needs a field as well as a border. That difference in the kind of illustration required is a simple test of what the five words actually ask a reader to notice.

Reading a catalogue across languages

Museum English can vary even between entries in the same database. One translator prints the name of a pattern together with the suffix ba, another uses the shorter stem, and a third describes the shape in English before supplying the Japanese word in parentheses. Search engines may separate these spellings into surprisingly different sets of results. Across the collection records linked below, an object name or accession number often serves as the most reliable way back to the same work. The accession can also guide a reader from an English entry to its Japanese counterpart and to additional photographs.

A second difference concerns the confidence of identification. The Kagemitsu has a date and name on its tang. The Mitsutada is attributed despite an alteration that removed the original identifying evidence. The Ishida Masamune has an established name and a history recorded in a later compilation. These distinctions should survive in any caption that accompanies a comparison of hamon. Describing a pattern accurately lends no additional certainty to a signature that is absent. Conversely, the loss of a signature does not empty an object's surface of evidence. A good catalogue lets the two statements stand together.

Modern viewers see another historical layer in the state of preservation and the conventions of photography. Polished steel can reflect a change in the direction or breadth of a light source so strongly that two images of a single work seem unrelated. A museum may publish a full view to record proportions and a different exposure to show the pattern. That pair is more informative than either alone. A photograph can establish that a visible feature occupies a particular part of the blade. By itself it cannot measure hardness, supply a date or assign the work to a particular hand.

For a final comparison, set the dated Kagemitsu beside the Ishida Masamune and the short blade in New York. Start with what the records actually let the eye verify: an inscription and carving on the first, the coexistence of waves and peaks on the second, and activity extending across the surface on the third. Then bring in the clove forms on the Mitsutada and the compact proportions of Atsushi Toshiro. Each adds a different question to the group. A vocabulary that began as five names ends as a way to notice what individual works preserve, what their catalogues explain, and what a photograph still leaves open.

Frequently asked questions

What is a hamon in a museum description?

It is the visible pattern associated with the hardened portion of a Japanese blade. Descriptions record its course, edge and related features in the surrounding steel.

How does suguha differ from notare?

Suguha follows a broadly straight course. Notare rises and falls in waves that are best recognized over a longer stretch of the blade.

How do gunome and choji differ?

Gunome emphasizes repeating rises and valleys. Choji evokes clove buds and can appear clustered. Real works may combine both.

Why is hitatsura different from the other four terms?

It describes the distribution of hardening effects well beyond the main edge zone. The edge itself can still have a recognizable wavy or clove-like outline.

Can one sword show more than one hamon style?

Yes. Tokyo National Museum describes both undulating and gunome forms on the Ishida Masamune. Their relationship depends on where and at what scale one looks.

Can the hamon identify a maker on its own?

A hamon can support comparison. Attribution also draws on shape, ground steel, tang, condition, historical records and other securely identified works.

Films and talks

The Met — The Japanese Sword and the Japanese Aesthetic

徳川美術館チャンネル — 徳川美術館 刀剣解説 展覧会見どころ紹介

Collection records and further reading

Related Articles