A sword dated twice
A visitor opening the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s record for a Japanese katana finds an unusually helpful piece of punctuation in the date field. The blade is dated to 1839. The mounting is assigned to the nineteenth century. The two statements occupy a single line, but they have different degrees of precision and depend on different evidence. The blade bears the name of Taikei Naotane. The guard carries the name of Yukinaka. Engraving on the blade itself is attributed to a third artist, Honjō Yoshitane. A photograph can show these contributions together more easily than a single date can describe them.
Kotō, shintō, shinshintō and gendaitō are a way of placing work like Naotane’s in a long history of Japanese blades. In this vocabulary his is a shinshintō blade. The term tells us roughly when he worked and points toward a particular conversation among craftspeople about earlier steel, shapes and reputations. The museum’s designation of the time as the Edo period also remains correct. A historian explaining daily life in a castle town and a curator comparing blades can put the same work into differently sized intervals. Neither has to give up an observation for the other to be right.
To get a feel for what the four terms accomplish, start with three dates that a visitor might copy from three labels. They are 1357, 1523 and 1839. The first two can both belong under kotō even though the political world and the organization of workshops changed profoundly between them. The third is much closer to the end of the Edo period than to its beginning. A good period scheme makes those relationships visible. Its value becomes especially clear when a surviving object confounds the expectation that everything made within an interval should look much the same.
Kotō and the geography of medieval craft
Kotō means old sword. In a four-part survey its field extends from the curved blades associated with the late Heian world across the Kamakura, Nanbokuchō and Muromachi periods and into the sixteenth century. Earlier objects, including ancient straight blades, can receive a separate heading in a fuller catalogue. This matters in a museum whose displays begin with excavated material. Calling kotō the first of these four periods does not make a late Heian tachi the earliest iron blade made in Japan. It identifies the starting point of a particular historical narrative.
Medieval production has a geography that generations of connoisseurs learned to describe through the five traditions, or gokaden. Yamashiro and Yamato evoke the cultural worlds of Kyoto and Nara. Bizen, Sōshū and Mino locate other influential traditions. Names of provinces, schools, workshops and individual smiths can all appear in the same entry, because they answer different questions. A reference to Osafune narrows a reference to Bizen. A signature naming a smith can narrow it again. A medieval blade outside the neatest examples of the five traditions still belongs in the period, and its existence helps show how selective the later scheme is.
The association of medieval production with local iron sands also needs a sense of scale. Access to raw material, transport, fuel, workers and patrons made a region a plausible home for workshops. The pattern visible on a particular polished blade, by itself, does not identify the river or deposit from which its material came. Written records of production and the results of material analysis operate at different levels from observations about surface appearance. Bizen makes an especially interesting case because the name can identify a historical province, a body of attributed workmanship or a model that later artists elsewhere set out to study.

The name Daihannya Nagamitsu offers an unexpected link between these medieval categories and later acts of remembering. Tokyo National Museum records a tradition that the tachi was valued at six hundred kan in the Muromachi period. The number suggested the six hundred fascicles of the Great Perfection of Wisdom Sutra, and the association supplied a name that endured. Someone searching the present collection under the name of a Buddhist scripture therefore finds a Bizen sword. The date of the blade, the setting of the valuation and the later history of the nickname are all parts of its biography. Only the first determines its place in the four-period scheme.
There is a further reward to looking up this particular record. The museum transcribes Nagamitsu as the actual signature and presents Daihannya as the celebrated name. Those two names can live side by side in a short label, with no implication that the smith knew what a later generation would call his work. A collector who starts with the nickname and a researcher who starts with the smith can thus reach the same object by entirely different routes. Its place in time gives them a common starting point for reading the evidence together.
A Tokyo National Museum exhibition checklist supplies an object with an unusually precise foothold in that long chronology. A tachi by Aoe Moritsugu carries an inscription dated to the second year of Enbun, or 1357. The name of Bitchū in the inscription places the work within a regional history distinct from neighbouring Bizen. The year locates it in the Nanbokuchō period. The visible shape of the object remains worth describing in its own right, but the inscription means the museum does not have to derive the entire date from the shape. An independent date is particularly valuable when comparing unsigned material.
The same exhibition list records an Osafune Sukesada work dated to the second month of Daiei three, or 1523. Its inscription names Bizen and Osafune. Both blades can appear on the kotō side of the chronological divide, yet more than a century and a half separates them. Calling both medieval is accurate and plainly insufficient for telling their individual stories. Once the dates have been recovered, comparison gets more interesting. One can ask which geographical names their makers chose to inscribe, how the museum presents those names in translation, and which historical changes took place in the interval.
What changed around Keichō?
The opening of the Keichō era in 1596 provides a widely used shorthand for the transition to shintō, or new swords. The word for new sword is written differently from Shintō, the religious term with a similar sound in English. Keichō also predates the establishment of the Tokugawa shogunate in 1603. The few years between the two markers explain an apparent inconsistency in many English accounts. An artist can be discussed at the opening of the new-sword period while a historian of government is still describing the consolidation that preceded Tokugawa rule.
| Catalogue label | Approximate chronology | A clue to check |
|---|---|---|
| Kotō | Medieval work, conventionally before 1596 | A province or school can narrow a broad period label. |
| Shintō | From around 1596 into the late eighteenth century | Separate a dated tang inscription from the date of the mounting. |
| Shinshintō | Late eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, conventionally to 1876 | Check the named smith and any explicit reference to an earlier school. |
| Gendaitō | Modern period, with usage varying by catalogue | Read the museum’s date and terminology for the individual object. |
Boundaries are conventional. Keep any more precise dating supplied by the institution that holds the work.
Sources · Japanese Sword Museum, Masahide in An’ei and Tenmei · Tokyo National Museum, dated medieval works in the Japanese Gallery
One change of lasting importance was the attraction of castle towns and large urban markets. A workshop could gain access to different patrons, collaborators and supplies by moving to a city. Osaka and Edo became conspicuous centres. Urban growth gave smiths trained in different regional environments repeated opportunities to encounter one another’s work. It also gave engravers, guard makers, lacquer workers and merchants a part in the same story. When a catalogue places several contributors to one finished ensemble in different locations, that distribution of names is evidence of relationships extending beyond a single forge.
The circulation of imported iron, often called nanban tetsu, is another strand in this history. Records of work by Yasutsugu include references to such material in inscriptions. An inscription can establish that a maker or workshop drew attention to a material and considered its origin worth recording. Claims about the chemical composition of an individual work require their own evidence. The development of trade opened choices for craftspeople. It did not send the same iron to every workshop on the same day, or make the traditional names of provincial schools cease to have meaning.

Changes associated with shintō are particularly visible in discussions of the hamon, the pattern along the hardened portion of a blade. Osaka makers are celebrated for compositions with a pronounced pictorial quality. Edo makers developed recognizable personal idioms of their own. A museum may direct light along a blade to show the fine detail within an outline that appears simple from across a gallery. Repeated arcs or a quiet straight passage are choices that can be compared across works. They also have histories long enough to frustrate any attempt to assign a century from one isolated motif.
The social life of a blade can complicate this chronology in a productive way. A family might preserve a medieval blade in an ensemble renewed for early modern dress. A later owner could commission new fittings without commissioning new steel. An exhibition of Edo costumes might show the complete assembly as evidence for how dress looked to contemporaries. An exhibition tracing medieval craftsmanship could show the blade beside it in a separate case. Each presentation selects evidence for a different question, and the same collection can support both. The dates in the captions keep the two arguments intelligible.
Shinshintō as a historical argument
In the late eighteenth century Suishinshi Masahide helped give renewed study of medieval work the force of a program. Shinshintō, literally a repeated “new” in the sword vocabulary, can sound like a promise of sheer novelty. A central ambition of the period was to understand what earlier makers had achieved. The combination is familiar elsewhere in the history of art. A craftsman looking back at surviving masterworks can be doing something quite new within his own setting. The selection of models, the way they are compared and the ability to discuss them with pupils all belong to his own time.
The boundary here is particularly instructive. The Japanese Sword Museum traces Masahide’s active career back to the An’ei era, beginning in 1772. In his compendium, historian Markus Sesko classifies blades made from around Tenmei, beginning in 1781, as shinshintō. The Japanese Sword Museum’s exhibition of Masahide, Naotane and Kiyomaro opens with a Masahide blade inscribed in the sixth year of An’ei, or 1777. The object can be dated with greater confidence than the moment when the revival became a movement. Rather than forcing the work onto one side of an invisible line, a curator can use it to show why transitions in artistic practice occupy time.
Masahide’s inscriptions also preserve something more intimate than the name of a movement. The Sword Museum’s exhibition checklist includes a paired set dated to the fourteenth year of Bunka. The inscriptions name an older Masahide and another artisan, Sadahide, and distinguish their contributions. On another work a patron’s request enters the inscription. These records give an unusually direct glimpse of the workshop as a social institution. The familiar portrait of a solitary artist rediscovering medieval secrets has little room for an apprentice or a patron. The objects themselves have room for both.

Taikei Naotane studied under Masahide. The Western Australian Museum preserves a work under Naotane’s name and discusses that relationship in the catalogue. In New York, the Metropolitan Museum’s blade dated 1839 offers a complementary view of his practice. The Met distinguishes the artist named on the blade from the attributed engraver and the named maker of the guard. When a second view shows the mounting in place, the visitor sees material for several histories at once. Japanese steel, carving, soft-metal fittings and lacquer each had communities of practice that could intersect around the work of one named smith.
Minamoto Kiyomaro supplies a different reason to read the exhibition checklist closely. The section devoted to him includes work signed Hidetoshi, work signed Masayuki and work signed Kiyomaro. A search for a single modern spelling of his best-known name would miss evidence of his career. Pairing the name on an object with its dated inscription allows the institution to place a work within a sequence. It also makes the language of attribution more precise. A label can identify the artist known to later readers as Kiyomaro while accurately transcribing a different name from the particular work in the case.
A nineteenth-century return to historical models made certain questions newly difficult for the twentieth-century curator. A work may display a feature associated with an earlier provincial tradition because its maker had studied that tradition closely. Finding such a feature in a nineteenth-century work is, in this sense, evidence that the revival achieved something. Assigning an earlier date to every successful evocation would erase the revival from view. Dated works by Naotane and his contemporaries supply a reference group in which to study that historical self-consciousness. An inscription provides the chronological anchor; the artistic similarities become the subject of inquiry.
Modern works and the changing meaning of new
The political restoration of 1868 and the sword-wearing proclamation of 1876 mark different developments. In a familiar four-period chronology, the latter supplies the conventional boundary for gendaitō, modern blades. The National Archives of Japan preserves the proclamation, with its exceptions tied to dress and public office. One can date that document to the day. A workshop’s loss of customers or success in finding new work follows a different calendar. Treating a change in public dress as a historical marker is useful precisely because we can then examine how long the consequences took to reach individual artists.
A blade by Gassan Sadakazu in Japan’s Cultural Heritage Online database carries the date December of Meiji twenty-seven, or 1894. Its inscription credits the maker with the carving as well. This is especially valuable beside the Metropolitan Museum’s Naotane. The earlier ensemble distributes credits among several names. The Meiji inscription draws two contributions together. Neither arrangement constitutes a rule for its period. Side by side, the records give concrete meaning to continuity of craft after the public wearing of swords was restricted. Sadakazu was still making, inscribing and dating work eighteen years after the proclamation.
The term shinsakutō draws attention to newly made work, particularly in the context of living craft and exhibitions of recent production. Gendaitō can cover a longer historical span and can carry a more specialized sense in catalogues concerned with modern methods of production. A caption for a work made in the nineteenth century and a programme for a contemporary exhibition may thus employ vocabulary differently. The practical question to ask of either is what dates, practices or makers the author includes. An apparently precise English expression such as “modern sword” becomes much more informative once those boundaries are stated.

Reading a case from left to right
Suppose a display contains a medieval work attributed to a province, an inscribed early modern blade and a nineteenth-century revival work with later fittings. A visitor can read the labels as three different kinds of historical argument. The medieval attribution draws on comparison with a body of related work. The inscribed object offers testimony in its own words, which specialists evaluate alongside its appearance. The composite ensemble preserves the choices of people who brought pieces together. No single numerical date has to express the relative evidentiary weight of all three cases.
There is a small discipline that makes this way of looking easier. Copy the museum’s most precise date and the exact noun it qualifies. In the Met entry the year applies to the blade. In an arms-and-dress exhibition it may instead apply to a mounting, a textile or a portrait showing how several items were worn together. Then copy the actual geographical designation. A province on a medieval inscription is a historically situated name. A modern city named in the museum credit may simply locate the present lender. Keeping those two lines apart prevents surprisingly large chronological errors.
Finally, look again at the two medieval dates with which we began. The years 1357 and 1523 have lost none of their individuality by belonging to kotō. The date 1839 now points to more than an artist toward the end of a shogunate. It identifies a participant in a network of revival scholarship, a collaborator within a complex craft economy and a work with a separately documented mounting. A good chronology gives a visitor the confidence to begin a comparison across a thousand years. The surviving names, dates and choices of the people who made these objects give that comparison a reason to continue.
Frequently asked questions
What are the four Japanese sword eras?
Kotō, shintō, shinshintō and gendaitō describe old, new, revival-era and modern works. Museum timelines may set slightly different boundaries for the first two transitions.
What is a kotō katana?
Kotō assigns the blade to the old-sword period, conventionally ending around the opening of Keichō in 1596. Katana identifies an object type, and the mounting may have a later date.
What is a shintō katana?
In sword catalogues shintō means new sword and refers to the early modern period. The word is written with different characters from the name of the religious tradition.
Where does shinshintō fit in Japanese sword periods?
It follows shintō in the late eighteenth century. Suishinshi Masahide, Taikei Naotane and Minamoto Kiyomaro exemplify different careers associated with this period of renewed study of older work.
When was the Edo period, and how does it fit this chronology?
The Tokugawa shogunate dates from 1603 and the Meiji Restoration from 1868. Shintō and shinshintō both overlap Edo history. The conventional modern-sword boundary often falls in 1876.
What is a hamon, and can it date a blade?
A hamon is the visible pattern associated with the hardened area of the blade. Later makers studied earlier patterns, so museums consider the whole object and its records when assigning a date.
Films and talks
The Met — Art of the Samurai—An Introduction
The Met — The Japanese Sword and the Japanese Aesthetic
Collection records and further reading
- Japanese Sword Museum, Masahide in An’ei and Tenmei
- Tokyo National Museum, dated medieval works in the Japanese Gallery
- Western Australian Museum, Taikei Naotane
- The Met, Naotane blade and associated fittings
- Cultural Heritage Online, Gassan Sadakazu’s dated work
- Japanese Sword Museum, exhibition checklist of Masahide, Naotane and Kiyomaro
- Tokyo National Museum, Daihannya Nagamitsu
- Gokaden (The Five Traditions): Identifying Yamashiro, Yamato, Bizen, Soshu, and Mino Sword Schools
- Markus Sesko, Nihontō Compendium, era chronology
