The 1876 Haitorei Sword Edict: Meiji Disarmament, Craft Crisis, and the Imperial Household Smiths

A proclamation and a bronze bird

A Japanese government proclamation issued in March 1876 and twelve bronze falcons exhibited in Chicago in 1893 belong in the same history. The first changed who could appear in public wearing a sword. The second showed an international audience what Japanese metalworkers could do with the surfaces of feathers, the texture of feet and the individuality of a bird at rest. Between them lay seventeen years of choices by artists, patrons, officials and exhibitors. The proclamation alone cannot tell us where an engraver found work the following winter. The birds alone cannot tell us which livelihoods disappeared before international exhibitors ever saw them.

A blade signed in Osaka in December 1894 makes a useful third witness. Its maker, Gassan Sadakazu, took credit for both the blade and its carving. He made it after the edict and before his appointment as an Imperial Household Artist. His career consequently upsets two easy assumptions about this period of Japanese history. Sword making continued to exist after wearing a sword ceased to be an ordinary privilege of status. It also continued in the years before the court formally recognized the two smiths now most closely associated with the survival of their craft.

The immediate question in 1876 concerned the body dressed for public life. A short legal text can have extensive consequences for people whom its authors never name. Every sword worn with dress brought together the labour of a smith, a polisher, a scabbard maker and workers in lacquer, braid and metal. An artist responsible for just the small metal cap at the end of a hilt could inherit a lifetime of highly specialized design knowledge. A change in what customers might wear was therefore also a change in the market for objects many observers could scarcely have identified individually.

1871 gave people a choice

The National Archives of Japan preserves a distinction easily lost when the changes of the Meiji era are compressed into an account of a single ban. In 1871 a proclamation left people free to cut their hair and lay aside their swords, in the context of changing conventions of dress. The language of permission is important. An individual could adopt a different appearance with official sanction. A person who continued an established practice had yet to encounter the more restrictive terms issued five years later. Translating both measures as an immediate command to give up swords removes that interval of choice.

Public appearance was unusually legible in a society where dress had long signalled rank and affiliation. Someone observing a street scene might have drawn conclusions about an individual from the ensemble at his waist, just as he might from a hairstyle or the cut of a garment. Changing the rules governing these visible differences affected both the wearer and the people who read them. The short document on dress belongs to the same political transformation as changes in office and social status. Its particular interest for a craft historian is how directly the state could affect demand by altering a social sign.

The Meiji Restoration is conventionally dated to 1868. Calling a change “Meiji” can compress more than four decades into the name of one reign. In this case the timing changes the argument. An image dated 1873 belongs after permission to discard swords and before the restrictive proclamation. A work made in 1880 belongs after both. To place either object accurately we need the dates of the measures as well as the broad political period. A surviving object may document an artist working through the transition even when the artist left no diary explaining how the new dress conventions affected his income.

What the March 1876 edict said

On March 28, 1876 the Dajōkan, the government council, issued Proclamation Number Thirty-Eight. The National Archives summarizes its subject as the wearing of swords. Its exceptions included formal court dress and members of specified services or public offices when in uniform. The conditions attached to those exceptions are just as revealing as the general rule. Public dress could still mark authority. The authority it marked was increasingly defined by an office, a uniform or a prescribed occasion. A blanket assertion that the measure prohibited every civilian object or closed every workshop misses the actual object of the text.

Haitōrei is the familiar historical name. In English the phrase “sword ban” is convenient for a search, yet it leaves out the verb that gives the original its meaning. The published archival description relates to wearing. It cannot establish that every old blade was confiscated, that every museum collection has its origins in this year or that all production was illegal. Those are separate historical claims. Evidence for a transfer to a collector might survive in correspondence or an accession ledger. Evidence for production after the proclamation survives on signed works such as Sadakazu’s. Precision about the verb opens those other lines of inquiry.

彫鐫画譜 Album of Designs for Metal Carving (Chōsen Gafu); 36.120.699, Metropolitan Museum of Art, view 3
彫鐫画譜 Album of Designs for Metal Carving (Chōsen Gafu); 36.120.699, Metropolitan Museum of Art, view 3. The Metropolitan Museum of Art.

The effect on visible fashions also helps explain an apparent paradox in surviving collections. The fewer people who could commission a complete mounting for ordinary public wear, the more informative an individual fitting could become when displayed on its own. A museum case lets a visitor see a minute detail without the rest of the ensemble obscuring it. A drawing or design album reverses the process again by preserving a composition apart from the metal on which it might once have appeared. Such records provide access to a working vocabulary that could move into a different branch of the arts.

A livelihood could change without leaving a signature

The town of Seki offers an industrial history quite different from that of an artist appointed to the court. Japanese government accounts describe local production expanding into household cutlery, including kitchen utensils and scissors. Here the continuity lies partly in a community of workers and its trade relationships. A family that made a succession of useful household goods might leave ample traces in business records and almost none in a museum exhibition of celebrated swords. The history of this transition therefore looks different depending on whether one starts in a collection of named masterpieces or in the industrial history of a town.

Scissors, tools for farm work and other implements are often mentioned together in accounts of displaced craftspeople. The surviving regional evidence has to bear the weight of each statement. A documented shift toward cutlery in Seki does not tell us the occupation of every former swordsmith in Osaka or Tottori. Nor does an exhibition of the most successful artists supply a census of workers who had to retrain. Estimates of the number affected require a geographical area, a date and a definition of the trades being counted. The objects presented here allow individual careers and a regional change to be documented with greater confidence than a single national total.

Much of the work that changed most dramatically was done in materials other than iron. Sword fittings had given engravers small surfaces on which to arrange a bird, a flowering branch or a narrative episode. They learned to make the image readable through colour differences in the metal and through variations in texture. A visitor can see a distinct challenge in the small hilt ornament depicting rice cultivation illustrated here. The design had to make sense on a component a few centimetres across. Its artistic qualities survived even after fewer patrons needed a complete set of fittings for dress.

Calligraphy and Painting Party, 1880, 1983.88
Calligraphy and Painting Party, 1880, 1983.88. Cleveland Museum of Art, Open Access.

An artist, a class and a new kind of customer

Consider a picture of cultural exchange made in the middle of this transition. Cleveland Museum of Art’s Calligraphy and Painting Party dates to 1880. The museum identifies Kawanabe Kyōsai as the artist of the figures and outlines, with ten literati completing works within the painted scene. Named contributors include a physician who also practised calligraphy. This is a picture of people making and responding to art for patrons. It provides evidence of a world in which authorship, expertise and patronage were shared. It does not purport to show the meeting at which a particular metalworker received a commission.

That distinction is worth retaining because the image gives a contemporary counterpoint to official records. A council proclamation presents a decision already made. A collaborative painting makes visible a company of people with overlapping abilities, ambitions and social connections. Artisans seeking work in a rapidly changing economy were part of such a social world. An appointment to a new school could depend on the standing of an individual as teacher as well as maker. An exposition display required someone to imagine what an audience overseas might understand and someone else to see the difficult work through to completion.

Kanō Natsuo’s career brings several of these routes together. Born in 1828, he had made his reputation in metalwork including sword fittings. In 1890 he became one of the first Imperial Household Artists. He also taught metalwork at the Tokyo School of Fine Arts. The exhibition history maintained by the Kiyomizu Sannenzaka Museum gives particular weight to his role as a professor. A court title records the recognition of a distinguished individual. A teaching appointment can have an effect extending far beyond the works carrying that individual’s signature, because students take what they learn into different workshops and categories of object.

The year of Natsuo’s appointment deserves a second look. Fourteen years had already elapsed since the proclamation about wearing swords. The Imperial Household Artist system was created in that later setting to sustain and encourage outstanding arts and crafts. Its remit reached well beyond sword making. Artists working in metal, paint and other media could all be recognized under a system of court patronage. When an English caption describes an artist as imperial, it helps to ask what the word modifies. An imperial artist could make work for several settings. The title alone cannot identify the intended recipient of every surviving piece.

Sword-Hilt Pommel (Kashira) with Rice Cultivation, Cleveland Museum of Art
Sword-Hilt Pommel (Kashira) with Rice Cultivation, Cleveland Museum of Art. Cleveland Museum of Art.

Twelve birds at the Chicago fair

Suzuki Chōkichi’s Twelve Bronze Falcons were made for the World’s Columbian Exposition of 1893. The National Crafts Museum identifies the group as an exceptional example of Meiji metalwork. The Japanese account of its designation credits the initiative of the dealer and organizer Hayashi Tadamasa and the direction and making of the work to Suzuki. Even that short description has several actors. The conception of a group that could hold an international audience, the material realization of twelve individual birds and the arrangements for an exposition were different achievements. Listing the artist’s name first need not cause the others to disappear.

Birds make particularly exacting subjects for anyone comparing work in coloured metal. A viewer expects to recognize a living individual in a slight inclination of the head or in a difference between compact feathers and longer flight feathers. Repetition across twelve perches might have made twelve almost identical figures monotonous. The group instead invited its audience to move from one to the next. The shift in scale from a fitting viewed in the hand to a group arranged for exhibition altered how viewers encountered detail. Surface treatments familiar from earlier craft could serve a larger composition intended to be seen in public.

International exhibition also changed the paperwork accompanying a work. A local commission might survive through an inscription, family papers and the object itself. A work sent to Chicago could also appear in a fair catalogue, a description prepared for visitors, photography, press coverage and later museum research. The history of the falcons has precisely this second kind of documentation. It enables a present-day reader to reconstruct an exhibition audience without assuming that every overseas buyer in the Meiji era was looking for the same form of Japanese art. A fair was a place of organized presentation as well as exchange.

In an exhibition of the Mito tradition, the Kiyomizu Sannenzaka Museum has traced another route through this change. Its selection brought together sword fittings, smoking utensils and vases from late Edo and Meiji workshops. The recurrence of artists and motifs across the categories is the valuable evidence. Some specialists continued producing fittings even as others pursued international buyers or turned to objects intended for furnished rooms. A category such as export metalwork can describe where an object was sold. It does not, on its own, describe the prior education of its maker or the other kinds of objects made in the same workshop.

Two smiths called to the court

The imperial appointments of Gassan Sadakazu and Miyamoto Kanenori came in 1906. The chronology matters as much as the honour. Thirty years separated their appointment from the proclamation of 1876. The first group of Imperial Household Artists had already been named sixteen years earlier. Sadakazu’s 1894 blade sits between these two institutional dates and demonstrates that a career could be active before its most prestigious official recognition. It is possible to admire an institution’s role in preserving craft while also noticing the sustained labour that made any such recognition possible.

Sadakazu’s dated inscription offers something that a general account of preservation cannot. It places an identifiable person in Osaka working on a particular object in a named month. His claim to the carving brings another component of the work within the same documentary frame. A later owner might change the mounting or add a storage inscription, yet the historical statement about the blade would continue to refer to the work of 1894. Museum records have an advantage here over commemorative portraits of a famous artist. They can reveal significant continuity in the decades before the portrait sitter received an official title.

Kanenori’s story also has a distinct regional setting. Kurayoshi City’s museum programming links him with Misasa in Tottori, and the Society for the Promotion of Japanese Sword Culture includes him alongside Sadakazu in its account of the appointments. Bringing him into the story allows a more accurate picture of what imperial patronage recognized. Two careers, with different regional associations and working histories, received the same distinction in the same year. The title added another chapter to both biographies. It did not erase the provincial craft communities in which their work had acquired meaning before the court took notice.

Covered Incense Burner, late 1800s, 1972.88
Covered Incense Burner, late 1800s, 1972.88. Cleveland Museum of Art, Open Access.

What a surviving object can prove

A covered incense burner in Cleveland, dated to the late nineteenth century, illustrates the range of objects that could occupy a Meiji interior. It belongs beside the records of fittings and of the Chicago fair as a point of comparison. No name has to be borrowed from an illustrious swordsmith to make the comparison worthwhile. The shape of a vessel, the place from which it was intended to be viewed and its relation to the table or stand beneath it set different problems for its maker. A museum can give visitors the means to see those differences without assigning all Meiji craft to one institutional story.

A productive visit to an exhibition on this subject might begin with a simple division of evidence. In one column put documents that changed what people could do, such as the proclamations on public dress. In another put dated evidence of what named individuals actually did, such as the Osaka inscription or Natsuo’s appointment. In a third put evidence about audiences, including the Chicago show and the record of the Japanese collection that now cares for the birds. Claims become more interesting once it is clear which of these columns supports them and which questions still require research.

The word survival can make the history sound more passive than the objects warrant. An artisan who adapted his work to a new domestic customer, a teacher who established a course in metalwork and a sculptor who conceived twelve different birds each exercised judgment about what could be carried forward. A museum can preserve those different choices in neighbouring cases. The day on which the state restricted what people wore remains essential to the chronology. The following decades belong equally to the people who found other places where their knowledge could be seen, taught and put to work.

Frequently asked questions

When were swords banned in Japan under the Haitōrei edict?

The proclamation of March 28, 1876 restricted the wearing of swords. It specified exceptions for formal court dress and designated personnel in uniform.

Why were samurai swords banned from ordinary public wear?

The restriction belonged to a wider reorganization of hereditary status and public authority. Exceptions tied public dress to state office and uniform.

What was the Meiji Restoration’s significance for sword artisans?

The political transition beginning in 1868 changed the patrons and institutions that sustained them. Exhibitions, schools and imperial commissions later offered opportunities to some makers.

What was the Meiji period for artists such as Kanō Natsuo?

During the Meiji period of 1868–1912, Natsuo brought experience in sword fittings into art education and became one of the first Imperial Household Artists in 1890.

What is a world fair, and which Meiji metalwork appeared at Chicago?

A world fair brought exhibitors from many countries together. Suzuki Chōkichi’s Twelve Bronze Falcons were made for the World’s Columbian Exposition in Chicago in 1893.

Who was Emperor Meiji in the story of imperial craft patronage?

He was the sovereign of Japan during the creation of the Imperial Household Artist system. Its appointments linked selected living artists and craftspeople to the court.

Films and talks

The Met — Conserving Japanese Works of Art in Foreign Collections

【刀剣ワールド】刀剣・日本刀・刀・剣 - YouTube動画 — 【刀剣ワールド】「刀剣博物館」刀剣に会える場所|刀剣展示 博物館の日本刀 YouTube動画

Collection records and further reading

Related Articles